Print Options

Irish Beef Stew

Irish Beef Stew

"Have I got the best recipe for you!" my friend Tomas announced, upon his return from a trip to photograph vineyards in Italy. "It's an Irish beef stew," he added, "and it's the best thing I've ever had." Apparently the chef at one of the wineries Tom was visiting prepared this stew for Tom, based on a Bon Appetit recipe, with the main difference being the substitution of Guinness (a very dark beer) and excellent red wine for some of the beef stock the recipe called for. Always eager to try new recipes with friends, I made my way to Tom's house and we cooked this up together for his family. As I suspected, the addition of Guinness and red wine makes all the difference.

Print Options

Irish Beef Stew Recipe

Ingredients

  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • 1 1/4 pounds well-marbled chuck beef stew meat, cut into 1-inch pieces (NOT extra-lean)
  • 6 large garlic cloves, minced
  • 6 cups beef stock or canned beef broth
  • I cup of Guinness beer
  • 1 cup of fine red wine
  • 2 tablespoons tomato paste
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 1 tablespoon dried thyme
  • 1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
  • 2 bay leaves
  • 2 tablespoons (1/4 stick) butter
  • 3 pounds russet potatoes, peeled, cut into 1/2-inch pieces (about 7 cups)
  • 1 large onion, chopped
  • 2 cups 1/2-inch pieces peeled carrots
  • Salt and Pepper
  • 2 tablespoons chopped fresh parsley

Method

1 Heat olive oil in heavy large pot over medium-high heat. Lightly salt the beef pieces. Working in batches if necessary, add the beef (do not crowd the pan, or the meat will steam and not brown) and cook, without stirring, until nicely browned on one side, then use tongs to turn the pieces over. Continue to cook in this manner until all sides are browned, about 5 minutes. Add garlic and sauté 1 minute. Add beef stock, Guinness, red wine, tomato paste, sugar, thyme, Worcestershire sauce and bay leaves. Stir to combine. Bring mixture to boil. Reduce heat to medium-low, then cover and simmer 1 hour, stirring occasionally.

2 While the meat and stock is simmering, melt butter in another large pot over medium heat. Add potatoes, onion and carrots. Sauté vegetables until golden, about 20 minutes. Set aside until the beef stew in step one has simmered for one hour.

3 Add vegetables to beef stew. Simmer uncovered until vegetables and beef are very tender, about 40 minutes. Discard bay leaves. Tilt pan and spoon off fat. Transfer stew to serving bowl. Add salt and pepper to taste. Sprinkle with parsley and serve. (Can be prepared up to 2 days ahead. Cool slightly. Refrigerate uncovered until cold, then cover and refrigerate. Bring to simmer before serving.)

Serves 4 to 6.

You might also like...

199 Comments

Hi...I made the Irish stew last night...and I must tell you that it is fantastic!!! My husband and I ran around all day yesterday getting the ingrediants...we used a stout ale...and Charles Mitchell Bella Rosa Italian style red wine...(we live up in Placerville) and have such great wineries in the area....I love your blog...and I plan on making lots of your yummy sounding recipes! The only different thing I added to the stew were whole fresh mushrooms...only because we love them...Great recipe..Thank-You! Vicci

Posted by: Vicci Henderson on September 11, 2005 9:14 AM

This looks exactly like the beef stew my mother has been making for ages. My family is welsh not irish but nontheless the stew is fantastic. We serve it with any hot crusty bread and lots of butter. This stew also freezes well if you take it off the heat just before the potatoes are soft (while they still have their corners). We ladle it into plastic containers and have stew all winter.

Posted by: Robin on September 13, 2005 9:28 AM

Day after tomorrow we're forecast to have lows into 40's - hurray! Here in OK that means opening the windows for the first time since April, taking long walks through the riotous color our sweetgums, dogwoods, and maples muster, slipping on acorns under the leaves, and trying not to step on the walking sticks. In anticipation I decided to try this recipe out. WOW! Delicious, a keeper! Very different from the usual beef stew.

I added an oxtail for richness (actually my husband, whom I had sent grocery shopping, bought a small package of stew meat instead of a large one, so ...), 2 shakes of McCormick's Montreal Steak seasoning for spice, and a sprig of fresh rosemary from the garden, as well as some oatmeal as a thickener. After browning the meat and combining all the ingredients in the skillet, I tossed everything except the potatoes and carrots into the crock pot for 5 hours. Added the veggies during the last hour. Fantastic! Thanks for posting it.

Posted by: sojourner on October 3, 2005 8:47 PM

I made this over the weekend. Wonderful rich flavor, and perfect for cold nights. I froze about half of it for later. I didn't have Guinness on hand so I used Newcastle Brown Ale, hopefully that was close enough. I also used Yukon Gold potatoes, yummy! The meat was incredibly tender and delicious. My husband ate two bowls of it for dinner tonight!

Posted by: Sheeijan on November 9, 2005 5:48 PM

This stew was absolutely scrumptious. My two picky eaters ate it up quick and asked for seconds. I used yukon gold potatoes and added celery, then served it in little bread bowls. Thank you for sharing this recipe! *Ü*

Posted by: Denise on November 16, 2005 4:03 PM

Amazing recipe. What a difference from your normal beef stew! I add lots of cremini mushrooms, a few extra bay leaves and use Yukon gold potatoes. I've tried making this without the guiness (using only red wine) but the beer makes it so much better. Thanks.

Posted by: Username167 on December 24, 2005 1:13 PM

This recipe is great... I lessened the thyme to 1 tspn and I added Kashi and celery to it. I also incresed the broth to 8 cups. The night I made it I served it to my husband and all the guys who work at our shop...it was a hit!!!

Posted by: allmyms on January 5, 2006 3:36 PM

I made this dish, used oxtails instead of beef stew meat, and cooked it for about 3 hours, until the meat was tender. I had no thyme, substituted herbes de provence, which is a blend of rosemary, marjoram, thyme and savory. I also omitted the potatoes, and served it with broad egg noodles, side salad and crusty bread. It was like velvet and my husband said it was one of the best stews he's ever had. The broth was so rich and dark. I will definitely keep this one handy for company.

Posted by: Mary on January 22, 2006 2:15 PM

Wonderful! My family LOVED this stew and I plan on it being a every Sunday dish!
Thanks!

Posted by: Charlotte on February 10, 2006 12:07 AM

Delicious! The best beef stew I ever made and ever ate!

Posted by: Colleen on February 13, 2006 8:14 AM

Great Stew! The added step of simmering the veggies in butter for 20min before adding them to the stew really pays off, it actually makes the veggies taste fresh. Now I am happy I bought a six pack of Guinness, I will have it for the next time I make Irish Stew...

Posted by: Catherine on February 13, 2006 10:05 AM

I've made this stew twice and it came out great both times,this last time I added 1 can of corn and 1 can of green beans to the recipe, and it turned out great! this is a stew you'd find in a resturant or a gourmet resturant! you just can't go wrong making it! and it smell so good when your cooking it!

Posted by: Mike on February 25, 2006 2:05 PM

I made this stew this weekend, used leftover wine that we didn't like on its own. The stew was AMAZING! An absolute must. Had some fresh sourdough bread to dip in and it was all to die for! This is the second recipe I've tried from your site, I love reading it every day! Thanks!

Posted by: Kate on February 27, 2006 7:49 PM

I just made it! So far so good. I didn't have Guiness but used Keiths Pale Ale instead. For wine I put Rosemount Estates Shiraz. And I added cabbage for more veggies. Boy does it ever smell good and the beef is so tender!

Posted by: CJ on March 2, 2006 1:02 PM

I don't think I've made stew in 10 years or more....I followed this recipe to the "T" and it turned out fantastic! I have turned over a copy of it to a friend whose parents have just opened an Irish Pub and are looking for some great dishes. They'll find it here.

Posted by: Denise on March 8, 2006 6:27 AM

I have made this twice. Once for the family to try it out and the next time for my supper club of 20 people. The flavor is wonderful (even when you triple the recipe!) Sauteeing the vegetables really brings out their flavor so they can compete with the Guiness and the wine. The thyme also adds a lot of flavor also. A big hit both times!

Posted by: Jewel on March 16, 2006 10:28 AM

I made this stew exactly as stated and it was delicious! My son-in-law said he has a "new" favorite meal...Irish stew served with Irish soda bread. And we have a new St Patrick's Day tradition. Thanks so much for sharing.

Posted by: Shari on March 17, 2006 6:06 PM

We made the Irish Stew on St. Patty's Day. We had guiness and irish cider with the stew and our movie to avoid the green beer crowd! Yum Yum! Thanks for the recipe. It will definitely be made again!

Posted by: Sarah on March 17, 2006 6:22 PM

Made this last night and it was delicious!!! Am eating the first part of the leftovers for lunch today and it seems to have got better!
Thanks.

Posted by: Barnaby on March 20, 2006 5:06 AM

It was a snowy blustery day in Omaha yesterday and we got a spring surprise! 10" or so of snow. My husband and I scurried around yesterday morning running our errands and getting the ingredients for this recipe and...it is FABULOUS! We served it with a good loaf of fresh french bread thickly sliced with lots of butter. We made exactly as directed and it was heaven on a snowy night! And the smell while it was cooking! As our buddie Rachel would say "Yumm-O"! This is definately a keeper.

Posted by: Trish on March 20, 2006 5:13 AM

Oh this is so good! Words can only begin to describe this flavorful comforting stew. By far the tastiest I have ever had. Will make this often, I'm sure. Great recipe.

Posted by: Jannmar on March 30, 2006 5:04 AM

This is a great stew full of texture and savory gravy, I have made it many times but this last time I froze it to serve after the birth of our first Grand Son.... It looked a little strange when it thawed but then it took on it's normal consistancy when heated....Now I plan to keep some on hand at all times in the Freezer.

Posted by: Cath on April 5, 2006 2:33 PM

OMG this stew is wonderful.. I mean hello this is life and live it to the fullest and trust me this stew makes you FULL... I mean this is the best this is my really first time cooking because now I am in college but this is so wonderful when I get a roomate I am going to make this for her the first night.

Posted by: carey on May 24, 2006 3:32 PM

Thank you so much. I and my Irish/German freind are having a guinness stew cookoff and we are being judged. This may give me a head start. Oh yeah here's another recipe you will need - guinness and potatoes. Drink the guinness forget about the stew!

Posted by: abel on June 2, 2006 6:11 AM

I live in Ireland, and that recipe is basically the same as my mum and granny's recipe! I love Irish stew - ya know it's not too warm over here(!), and some steaming hot Irish stew is always a great dinner after a long day. :-)

Posted by: Caoimhe on September 1, 2006 3:40 PM

I am a huge fan of beef stews, I've made em with many different beers, many different wines, but I've never thought of using both! Definitely my new favorite! A couple of adjustments I made the second time around were: I roasted, peeled, and crushed a couple of tomatoes and added a small amount of tomatoe sauce I made instead of using the tomato paste. I also added celery and used fresh thyme with the veggies instead of the stew. Thanks for the great recipe!!!!

Posted by: Jared on October 5, 2006 2:10 PM

Wow...this stew is amazing. Loved it! This will definately go into the dinner rotation.

Posted by: ren on October 5, 2006 7:26 PM

This is the first time making this. It is on the stove right now simmering and the condo smells fantastic. I moved from Missouri to Florida a year ago and I had forgotten about stews in general. We are looking at a frosty 68 degrees tonight so it will be perfect. Really!

Posted by: Dylan on October 7, 2006 4:50 PM

This is a great recipe for crockpots. I cooked the meat and started it on the crockpot with the broth and Guinness. Then, I added vegetables for the last two hours or so after sauting them.

Two great substitutions: I substituted half the potatoes with a yam; and I substituted California Masala (a sherry-like wine) for the wine. Simply AWESOME.

The tomato paste does a good job of thickening it. If you want a bit more thickness...Add a teaspoon of cornstarch to a bit of broth and add the mix slowly 10 minutes or so before serving it.

Posted by: tj on October 8, 2006 4:07 PM

This sounds delish but I will be serving this to several children and adults. Is the beer and wine taste too strong for children? Or do the flavors mellow with the cooking?

Posted by: Pam on October 20, 2006 6:39 PM

I live in Japan and often miss some of the flavors I'm used to stateside. I'd been craving a good Irish Beef Stew for a while, and I can't visit the Old Irish bar back home, so I made this one.

This is a WONDERFUL recipe. My mother-in-law and wife (both Japanese) absolutely LOVED it. This is a recipe that I will be keeping in the recipe box and making often in the winter. Relatively easy to make and freezes very well.

I did vary the original recipe a bit, by adding 1 1/2 cans of Guinness and some peas and corn. Also, I had difficulty finding Worcestershire sauce so I sub'ed a Japanese sauce that's "similar."

To Pam: the wine and beer mellow out wonderfully and there's no discernable alcohol taste. They'll love it.

Posted by: J on October 23, 2006 9:55 PM

This stew was utterly incredible............the best I have ever made. I added pearl onions and 160z. of frozen peas. Thanks for the recipe! YUMMY

Posted by: barrie allen on October 23, 2006 10:07 PM

Delicious! I've made this twice, once using Guiness and another time using a much lighter beer- they both turned out great but I must say that the Guiness really makes a huge difference in the flavor. I served the stew the day after preparing it, with hot biscuits... it was the perfect meal for a cold night!

Posted by: Jessie on November 1, 2006 11:55 AM

Why is this recipe called Irish stew?

Posted by: gerry gourley on November 6, 2006 10:26 AM

I'm half Irish/German, and I love collecting Irish and German recipes. This is THE BEST STEW, and I served it with Beer Bread(so easy to make, and so delicious with this stew!). I found the red wine garlic and beer really MADE this what it is. My boyfriend is from India, so I served this with rice (he put it over his rice) and he thought it was fantastic too! This is a keeper.

Posted by: Traci on November 13, 2006 10:42 AM

Made this for the first time tonight. Was a hit. I used Yukon Gold potatoes and used a smoked hamhock for extra flavor.

Posted by: Kelsey on December 2, 2006 7:50 PM

This was a wonderful recipe. I took the veggies and meat out right the veggies were done and reduced the sauce quite a bit for more flavor and texture. I seasoned the meat with salt and pepper before browning (kinda surprised the recipe doesn't call for that) ... I also used tomato sauce instead of paste and used a big 'ole can of Guinness.

I will be serving this to my fiance for dinner tomorrow, along with some creamed and cheesy grits. Thanks for a wonderful recipe. The house smells AWESOME.

Karin, Chicago

Posted by: Karin on December 14, 2006 4:09 PM

It's my first time cooking for the whole family and they loved this stew. Thumbs up! I will definitely cook this again!

Posted by: Jenny on December 25, 2006 5:40 PM

I tried this recipe & fed it to two of the hardest to please men that I have ever met. Not only am I forever in their good books but I am now commited to preparing it for them once a week for the duration of this winter. I guess it just goes to prove there can be to much of a good thing.

Posted by: Kay Turner on January 15, 2007 7:59 PM

Made this stew today and it was fantastic.... I did all the prep work then threw it in the crockpot to simmer for the day...I'll be making this again.

Posted by: Ellen on January 21, 2007 12:16 PM

I made a double batch of this for ten friends yesterday. It was delicious! I was juggling cooking and teaching lessons all day, so I rushed the vegetable saute step, and cooked the stew longer than recommended. As a result (I think), the potatoes broke down a bit, making the stew a bit pasty. Even overcooked, it was delicious. I look forward to making this on a weekend!

Posted by: Rob on January 26, 2007 1:03 PM

Any tips on how to adapt this for a slow cooker? It sounds like it would be simple to do, but I'm not the most accomplished cook and wouldn't know how much time to add to the recipe, or whether to cook on high or low. I'd also have to omit bringing it to a boil. Any thoughts?

Posted by: Sarah on January 30, 2007 12:04 PM

To Gerry Gourley - Its called Irish Stew cacause the ingredients are basically what the Irish farm folk used to make a hearty stew on a rainy nite. I doubt red wine was involved - maybe a splash of Jameson's Irish Whiskey = and you can substitute lamb for beef with equally good results.

Posted by: Paradise Pat O'Sullivan on January 30, 2007 12:37 PM

This was such a yummy dish! I made this for my boyfriend as the main dish for Christmas dinner. It lasted for not only a week but tasted even better as each day passed. This is definately a keeper recipe in my house! Thank you!

Posted by: Jaime on January 30, 2007 5:17 PM

This is excellent! I was looking for a stew without dredging the meat in flour and this recipe caught my eye. I made this a month ago and it was delicious! My family also likes dumplings (e.g. Bisquik) with stew, so I made those and simmered on top of the stew before serving. I am making the recipe again today for company, and the only change I will make is to add celery.

Posted by: Kelley on February 10, 2007 3:37 AM

I made this dish last night and my husband and I both agreed that this is the most DELICIOUS stew we have ever tasted. Made it with crusty buttered bread heated in the oven and a simple green salad. The flavors in this stew are intense and the aroma while cooking is heavenly.

I had it for lunch today as well and I think it will be dinner again tonight. It's that good!

Posted by: Susan on February 20, 2007 2:24 PM

Please help me! I am making an Irish Stew for St. Pat's Day for about 50 people. Does anyone have approx amt of ingredients for this large amount? I have a very limited budget so any shortcuts would be appreciated.

Posted by: Marge on February 24, 2007 7:17 PM

WOW! made the recipe exactly as it was.
Had 7 people for dinner and used large Ciabetta buns hollowed out as bowls for the stew to sit in on the plate. Thinking that the bowls would be left over I was WRONG there, everyone devoured the bowls and the stew. I even loved the meal which is not usually the case when I do the cooking for a dinner party. SUch a relaxed meal to have with company the stew and a ceasar salad and it was perfect.
BRAVO!! wouldn't change a thing I am back on your site today looking for more recipes
Thank You for sharing

Posted by: Susan Clark on March 3, 2007 7:25 AM

I made this stew last week, everyone loved it! I just added peas. The beer and wine really gave it a kick.

Posted by: Lori Dwyer on March 12, 2007 9:23 AM

I'm an Irish Brat and this stew is very tasty. I followed the recipe but added more salt & pepper only, then served w/rice, corn, & asiago cheese bread & butter! I read a comment above on adding cabbage, I will try that next time. THANKS!

Posted by: pturnipseed on March 13, 2007 12:29 PM

I made this stew for my team at work. They and I loved it! Quite frankly, it may be the best tasting stew I've ever had. I served it simply with soda bread.

Posted by: Laurie Bertram on March 16, 2007 12:05 PM

There was a question earlier in this thread about whether Guinness is made with wheat. Guinness is made with roasted barley malt, not wheat. But I don't know whether barley adversely affects those requiring wheat-free diets.

Posted by: pfzlsk on March 16, 2007 11:49 PM

Hi Pfzisk,
People on wheat-free diets are usually trying to avoid gluten, which is a component of barley as well as wheat. Beer, stouts, and ales are usually off the list of approved foods for people on this kind of restricted diet.

Posted by: Elise on March 17, 2007 12:01 AM

Well done Elise! I just made two dishes with Guinness - one posted and another on the way. It gets to you, doesn't it!

Posted by: Trig on March 17, 2007 9:02 AM

I mentioned this recipe to my cousin with the fact that the stock had red wine and Guinness. He replied how he had a Guinness Cheesecake a few years ago and it was excellent. I did a quick google and found the following to share with all of you:

Guinness Cheesecake

From Denver chef Robert McCarthy, based on his popular "Shot and a Beer" cheesecake. Makes one 8-inch cheesecake.

Ingredients

1 1/2 cups chocolate cookie crumbs
3 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
1 teaspoon sugar
1 1/2 pounds cream cheese, room temperature
1 cup sugar
3/4 cup Guinness Stout
2 eggs
1 yolk
1 cup chocolate sauce
1 tablespoon Irish whiskey (or to taste)

Directions

Preheat oven to 325 F

Combine cookie crumbs, butter and sugar in a large bowl, and spread evenly over the bottom of a 6-inch springform pan. Bake at 325 for 12 minutes. Let rest 30 minutes.

Beat cheese and sugar until smooth. Add Guinness and eggs, and mix well, scraping sides frequently. Bake in a waterbath for 1 hour 15 minutes to 1 hour 45 minutes until center is set. Cool for 45 minutes, then cool overnight in the refrigerator.

To serve, allow cheesecake to come to room temperature. Warm chocolate sauce in a small double boiler or in a microwave. Stir in whiskey and drizzle sauce on and around the cheesecake.

Posted by: Josh on March 17, 2007 12:34 PM

If you are lucky enough to access to good, fresh stewing LAMB instead of beef, then your stew will be much more authentically an Irish Stew.

Posted by: ben on March 18, 2007 12:39 AM

This is super duper delicious!

Posted by: Anita on March 19, 2007 9:37 AM

Hi Elise

Thanks for posting this tasty looking recipe. I made Beef Jaapanese Curry served over rice but wondered how to make a goodbeef stew. I have question, can you replace the beer or wine with more beef stock?

Linda

Posted by: Linda on March 19, 2007 4:38 PM

This was much better than other recipes that I have made. The wine and beer in the broth made all the difference. Didn't have any Guinness, so I used Newcastle Brown Ale. I also think that sauteeing the veggies added to the flavor. Will definitely make again.

Posted by: Amy on March 21, 2007 6:24 AM

This was truly the tastiest beef stew that I have ever made! My family all thought that it was sooo good, especially with wonderful fresh crusty bread to soak up the incredible broth. No more insipid stews for us.
Thanks so much, Elise.

Posted by: Cynthia on March 21, 2007 10:04 AM

Hi Elise,

Your stew recipe is fabulous. Even my young daughters enjoyed it and they are both picky eaters. I did have to separate the meat from the vegetables and they didn't eat it in true stew form but it worked. And my wife and I loved it.

Posted by: G. Stephen on April 12, 2007 9:59 AM

I have made this recipe twice and it really is everything it promised. Hearty, velvety, buttery and absoultely delicious. I added baby bella mushrooms, pearl onions and a little cayenne pepper. One of the best tasting dishes I have either made or eaten! Plus it's easy!

Posted by: M. Prakash on May 15, 2007 1:03 PM

I made the stew. I think it came out ok. Tastes similar to the potroast I've made in the past. I just don't think it lived up to the hype. It was quite a bit of prep work and time and it came out like regular beef stew. Ultimately, my husband and I were dissappointed.

Posted by: Meredith on May 21, 2007 3:51 PM

This is one of my favorite recipes now and I love your site! I had looked long and hard for the perfect Guinness beef stew recipe and this is the one for me! The addition of the wine is great, too. Thanks for your site-it inspired me to try to post my feeble attempts as well.

Posted by: aptcook on May 28, 2007 12:09 PM

This will be the third time I make this recipe. I absolutely love it! Just make sure you don't overcook the veggies.

Posted by: Avelina on June 1, 2007 8:14 AM

We are very happy to have found this recipe! We like the convenience of making it up and then freezing ahead of time to take on fishing and camping trips.To adjust for our taste, we added a 2 lb. bag of parsnips peeled, then chunked up in similar size to the potato pieces, yummy!As a thickener..... 1 TBSP uncooked tapioca per cup of remaining liquid (judge by eye) stirred in with 5 mins remaining cooking time.

Posted by: Pam on June 10, 2007 5:18 AM

Yep, slight variations in my attempt, but great start point! Thanks!

Posted by: A on June 17, 2007 9:04 AM

Guinness is a stout, not a beer!

Posted by: Irish on July 8, 2007 2:16 PM

I first made this stew about 6 months ago and have made it for nearly every friend that has come to our house for a meal, the best stew I have ever had, very rich, thanks for the recipe!!

Posted by: john howarth on July 10, 2007 4:17 AM

This was our dinner tonight- delicious! I simmered the beef much longer than an hour- something like 3 hours- until it was tender, and added chunks of celery as well.

And because we didn't have Guinness in the house, I used a local dark lager called Cerveza Negra. So tasty and perfect with rice. Thanks!

Posted by: Lorraine on August 6, 2007 9:28 AM

I tried this for the first time last night and followed the recipe exactly. My husband, Richard, commented beforehand "I've never really been much for stews" but I was determined to give this recipe a try, regardless. Half-way through the cooking he popped into the kitchen to say "Hey that does smell good!" When I finally served it with chunks of warm bread he hardly said a word through dinner (that's a first!) and at the end said "I don't know what to say to you. That was the best stew I have ever tasted - it was fantastic!" If Richard raves about it, it must be good. Thank you for helping me give the impression to my husband that I am indeed a wonderful cook!

Posted by: Linda Sinclair on August 23, 2007 6:47 AM

This looks perfect! I was looking for a stew recipe to cook for about 16 adult males this weekend (poker retreat). Are there any considerations I need to take into account when tripling (quadrupling?) this recipe?

Posted by: dave on September 27, 2007 12:15 PM

Well the recipe sounds wonderful, I am off to the grocery store now and can't wait to start making. I cook for a living, so I'll let ya know what I think.

Posted by: Billy from British Columbia on October 1, 2007 5:00 PM

Really nice stew. The stout adds a special depth as does the red wine. I added a head of broccoli aswell and it was rich and beautiful. I think all the beef stews i make in the future will be of this recipe - thanks

Posted by: kylie on October 4, 2007 2:39 AM

This stew turned out really really well! I'm not going to use quite as many potatoes next time, but the flavor was just perfect! Thank you =)

Posted by: Kim on October 10, 2007 7:02 AM

This was wonderful. I braised the meat, but all else the same. Everyone loved it!

Posted by: M.J.S. on October 11, 2007 11:54 AM

I am making this right now. It's unbelievably delicious. I only used 1 1/2 lbs of red potatoes (unpeeled) and added 4-5 stalks of celery and another 1/2 onion. Wow! We are going to have it with some onion rye country bread.

My husband didn't think he liked stew... but he sure has changed his mind! He keeps asking when it's going to be ready... 10 more minutes, sweetheart!

Posted by: stephanie on October 12, 2007 4:07 PM

I've never commented on anything I found online, but this is worthy of a comment. A cool Southern California day had me itching for stew and yours is the best I've ever tatsted. Thanks for sharing!

Posted by: tammy on October 15, 2007 7:09 PM

The recipe says simmer covered for an hour and while it is simmering saute the potatoes and onions add and simmer 40 minutes un covered. So is the total simmering time 1 hour or an hour and forty minutes?

Note from Elise: The total simmering time is one hour and forty minutes.

Posted by: Brian on October 19, 2007 9:58 AM

This is a delicous stew! The smell that was throughout the 'house' was fantastic we could not wait for it to be finished!!!
What a wonderful meal full with flavour!
My family enjoyed it very much~yummy!

Posted by: Sonia Pizzinato on October 27, 2007 5:15 PM

Being that it's that time of year, I was looking for a good stew recipe and came upon this one. I used the chain meat from a tenderloin and rolled the carrots, potatoes and onion in a little flour before browning in the butter and it turned out FANTASTIC! I am just starting out experimenting with beer in cooking and this dish inspired me to use it much more. Thanks!

Posted by: PandaSlayer on October 28, 2007 10:37 AM

FABULOUS STEW! I realized I had no guiness after I had started the recipe so I left it out and it was still the best stew I've ever had. Cooking the vegetables before adding them to the meat intensifies the flavor and they don't end up soft and watery. The meat was tender and flavorful and the "juice" was very tangy and delicious. Be sure to serve with a good bread so you can sop it up.

Posted by: Terrie Hall on October 29, 2007 9:20 AM

We found a sale on whole Tri tip instead of stew meat and added twice as much wine and beer with a few extra spices and took maybe an extra hour to reduce during our hour long bike ride. Was delicious thanks for posting!

Steve

Posted by: Steve on October 30, 2007 11:18 PM

I made this last night for the family and everyone absolutely loved it! I also made some irish soda bread to go with this and it's an out of this world combination!

Posted by: Wesley on November 4, 2007 1:06 PM

I made this with lamb (cut up leg of lamb) and it was outstanding!

Posted by: Hanna on November 19, 2007 2:24 PM

Tried this recipe for the first time yesterday for my greek friends and family and it was a huge success .... looked JUST like the photo too!! Followed it exactly ... very easy to make, just a little time needed for preparation .... I would also say that this recipe would not be suitable for more than 4 people ...
Try it... trust me, if I can make it, anyone can!!

Posted by: Teresa on November 21, 2007 11:21 PM

I made this stew tonight-- added a bit of celery and chopped leeks. Also I added sherry instead of the wine. To thicken it for a meat pie filling, I added some whole wheat bread pieces which worked very well!

Posted by: CS on November 23, 2007 5:05 PM

This is how I like it too. The only major difference is that I buy a 4 pack of guinness cans and i drink them while I wait for the stew.

Posted by: Frank on November 28, 2007 5:47 PM

I made this tonight and it was awesome. I used some yellow baby potatoes instead of russets. Also, I used rosemary instead of bay and pearl onions instead of a large onion.

Next time I might add barley to it. Very yummy!

Posted by: Liana on November 30, 2007 7:36 PM

I made this stew yesterday for 12 people. The only difference I made was that I added a little chillies and frozen peas and let it simmer for about 3 hours. Absolutely wonderful Everyone loved it. Will definitely be doing it again. Thank you.

Posted by: saviour deguara on December 13, 2007 3:46 AM

Thank you so much for this recipe! I have made it at least 6 times now and each time it has been delicious. (I now add a whole 500ml can of Guinness and 3/4 of a bottle of wine to the recipe....makes it even more divine :-) )

Posted by: Tracey Dublin on December 29, 2007 4:13 PM

Just made it tonight and loved it!

Posted by: Kirsten on January 2, 2008 6:13 PM

I love this recipe. Every time I make it, the whole pot just...disappears!

Posted by: Ryan Oakes on January 4, 2008 9:18 AM

Can I cook this stew in the oven instead of on the stovetop?

Posted by: liz on January 4, 2008 11:20 AM

Thank you very much for posting this recipe! I am cooking it right now and the sauce tastes so goooood.... More power to you!!!!

Posted by: Special K on January 6, 2008 3:55 PM

My husband made this tonight and even the kids loved it! I did a post at my blog on this recipe.

Posted by: Kelly on January 6, 2008 9:30 PM

I just finished making this stew, I've been wanting to make my own Guinness stew since I tried one at the local Irish Pub, This recipe was awsome. I made it for my mom, girlfriend and a good buddy and everyone loved it. I added a full pint of guinness instead of the 1 cup and also added celery but all in all this was great. I will be making it again soon for some more friends.

Posted by: Justin on January 21, 2008 1:28 PM

Another great addition is celery.

Posted by: colin on February 11, 2008 5:11 PM

Amazing! I made this last year for a Pub Night fundraiser for our Irish Dance Team - made enough for 100 people. We sold out in 20 minutes - people were stealing tickets from others because they wanted seconds! Will be making enough for 300 this year!

Posted by: Valerie on February 23, 2008 11:31 PM

Does anyone know if this stew could be made without the tomato paste? It sounds so good otherwise, but I am just not a fan of soups/stews with a strong tomato flavor.

Posted by: morgan on February 24, 2008 10:01 AM

Went ahead and made it without the tomato. Delicious!

Posted by: morgan on February 26, 2008 1:21 AM

Your recipe was fantastic!!! The flavor of the beer and wine was incredible, I had it for dinner tonight. This is going to be a great recipe for St. Patrick's day. Thank you for the recipe!!!

Posted by: Bryan on March 4, 2008 5:19 PM

i must have done something wrong....this stew had absolutely NO flavor. 5 bites and we were done. what started as irish stew turned into 2 apples and crackers for dinner.

The stew is only as good as the ingredients you put in it. For example, you can't use any old beef, you need to use stew meat - tough cuts that are intensely flavorful and perfect for slow cooking. Use the best quality beef stock you can get your hands on. Your herbs need to be no more than a year old. The wine should be a good drinking wine, not cooking wine, etc. Browning the meat initially is very important for the resultant flavor as well. ~Elise

Posted by: Anonymous on March 5, 2008 6:31 PM

Thanks so much this recipe was delicious! My husband has always loved Irish Stew and talked about his Gran making it! He really enjoyed it-have NEVER seen him mop up everything with bread! It was the first time I had made or tasted Irish stew myself and it was fantastic. Will definitely be a weekly meal now through autumn and winter ... also we got 2 and a half meals out of it (so great to just have to reheat with a young baby!) -and if possible it tasted even better the second night! Am going to try it using the crock pot next time.

Posted by: Maddie on March 11, 2008 3:00 AM

Wow, Guinness and red wine are basically the only 2 types of alcohol that I will consume. This sounds incredible.

Posted by: Nick on March 15, 2008 12:37 PM

This stew is wonderful and if you say it isnt ...you did something wrong ...my family BEGS for me to make this and they are finicky eaters. Thanks

Posted by: Patty on March 16, 2008 11:07 AM

I made this stew tonight for St. Pattys day!
It was very good and flavorful. I followed the directions exactly - except I poured the whole bottle of guiness in 11.7 oz - no sense wasting it. it was very good and my husband had two bowls!

Posted by: felonice on March 16, 2008 7:58 PM

I made this stew to take along to St. Arnold's brewery here in Houston for their St. Patty's day celebration. It was absolutely delicious, really easy to make, and went perfectly with stout, amber, & brown ales!

Posted by: KiKi on March 17, 2008 7:57 AM

My family's beef stew recipe is fantastic, so this one had a lot to live up to. The Guiness and red wine made it really incredible!!! And sauteeing the veggies was a lovely idea.

As for improvements, I love thyme, but 1 Tbsp was really too much for my taste. Mushrooms and/or celery would be great additions. Also, the stew was rather thin, even after I added some corn starch. Maybe less stock next time.

I bet it will be thicker today though, and even more flavorful - I can't wait for the leftovers!

Posted by: Julie on March 17, 2008 8:45 AM

I'm Irish and I often make a similar stew to this! It seems to go down well with anyone I've served it too especially if I make my homemade brown soda bread to mop it up with.

Posted by: Jenny on March 18, 2008 9:10 AM

We were married in Ireland nearly 5 years ago and we spent 2 weeks touring Ireland, staying in B&B's and stopping in pubs for a bowl of soup and a 1/2 sandwhich every day for lunch. I ate some really nice beef stew while I was over there so I'm hesitant to try to make it on my own, for fear it won't live up to what I remember.

Still, this recipe looks good so I'll have to try it. Thanks for sharing!

Posted by: Overwhelmed With Joy! on March 20, 2008 7:45 AM

I made this stew tonight, and my family loved it. My only change was that rather then letting the beef simmer for 1 hour, i simmered it for 4 hours and added 1 - 1/2 cups more beef broth. Then i put the veggies in. My pickiest child, in the house even liked it!


thanks!

Posted by: carrie m on March 26, 2008 4:37 PM

Thank you for sharing this fab recipe with the world! I made this for my parents and they absolutely loved it! I cooked it for 4 hours and the beef was so tender it literally melted in your mouth. I'm now going to attempt a second try and make it for my partner tonight so fingers crossed it should turn out just right again. If anyone reading this is umming and rrring about whether to make this or not - make it!!! It's truly amazing, especially the wonderful aroma it produces in the kitchen. Enjoy!!

Posted by: Amanda Gillam on April 10, 2008 3:14 AM

What kind of wine would one use with this? anything specific I am wondering? Certain wines are very different and I would not want to mess this one up.

Use a red wine that you like to drink. Whatever you do, don't buy a cheap cooking wine for this. If you don't like the wine on its own, it's not going to be great in the stew. ~Elise

Posted by: Mike on May 18, 2008 4:11 PM

Made this yesterday and it was a huge hit, even with my little toddler. The Guinness definitely is uncompromisable. As for the red wine, I just used the red wine I had on hand...it was a simple table wine, and it still came out great. Next time I'm going to simmer the meat longer than an hour and add an extra cup of broth along with the entire can of Guinness instead of 1 cup. I'm also not a huge fan of carrots and felt like they didn't soak up the flavor of the stew too well, so I will be putting in whole mushrooms instead. The first day we served it with bread, the next day we poured it over cooked white rice and it was soooo good. I'm so happy I made this! :)

Posted by: alyssa on May 19, 2008 6:24 PM

I've been trying to mimic the Guinness pie from an Irish restaurant we have here near Worcester, MA for a while now, and this one comes pretty close.
The flavors and texture are both great, though to get closer to my preferred taste, I will probably use a couple extra bay leaves, forgo the wine in favor of more stout, and use lamb next time. But even un-monkeyed around with, this is a fine dish.

Easy & cool serving variation: Before serving, ladle the stew into large individual oven-safe ramekins or pie plates. Top with ready-made pie crust and bake according to the package directions.

Posted by: John Swayze on June 7, 2008 2:12 AM

P.S. - One other modification I forgot to mentioned I used.

We like a thicker stew, so once the final simmer was done, I evacuated the meat and vegetables to an aluminum foil-covered bowl and thickened the remaining liquid with a simple roux.

I let that cook for a couple of minutes to thicken to a more gravy-like consistency, then put everything back in the pot and stirred it all together one last time.

Posted by: John Swayze on June 7, 2008 2:20 AM

I made this recipe for my boyfriend's birthday and he loved it. He said it was better than his grandma's stew (who is Irish!). Even I thought it smelled wonderful and I am a vegetarian! Next time, I will probably add more meat.

Posted by: Pascale on June 10, 2008 9:34 AM

Looks like a great recipe, but reminds more of a French Beef Bougingnon than traditional Irish Stew (note the red wine, roux and tomato paste). None the less, I'll try it out, but don't think I'll be able to make myself use dried thyme.

Posted by: Ken on July 17, 2008 8:11 AM

Wow! I made this stew the other night for dinner, it's the first stew I've ever made (I don't cook regularly) and it was absolutely awesome! I used more meat than called for and slightly less potato butnone the less....wow! My mom even said it was great (she ate the whole bowl I served her and she doesn't generally eat a lot) and she wants me to share the recipe with my uncle who's a chef. Wonderful!

Posted by: susie on July 26, 2008 7:17 AM

THANKS FOR THIS RECIPE! Followed it to a T except for the bay-leaves (didn't have any) and added some corn starch just to thicken it right at the end.

Fantastic recipe and better than a lot of the "irish" stews I've had (Lived in Ireland for 5 years)

Posted by: Fae on August 23, 2008 10:02 AM

I will be the odd one out here and say that I really did not enjoy this at all. I found it kind of not tasty. My biggest issue is that even after I chilled it and removed the top layer of fat I found the thing too oily. Most likely I put the blame on the fact that I had been cooking for six hours straight and this was the last thing on the menu and I probably ran out of that "love filled urge" to cook- and without my desire for making the dish and being tired I probably messed it up somehow, but if I do try to make it again I will have to cut down on that oil in the beginning- and maybe I used the wrong type of pot (Le Creuset dutch oven?) Who knows, maybe I am just not a stew person?

Posted by: Anna on August 24, 2008 2:20 AM

I made this stew once already to very rave reviews!, now I need to double/triple it and I do not have any beef stock in the house, however I do have a nice red wine, and 3 cans of guinness? Will that do?, or is the beef stock that important?

You can try it and see. At a minimum I would use beef bouillon cubes. Personally I would not attempt to make this stew without the stock, but that's just me. ~Elise

Posted by: Denise on August 24, 2008 6:44 AM

Many many thanks for sharing this delicious recipe. It is simply fantastic!

Posted by: Syida on September 17, 2008 12:52 AM

If I wanted to transfer and simmer in a slower cooker, how long would it need to simmer for?

Posted by: Lorraine on September 18, 2008 6:24 PM

One thing I've noticed.... when ever I make a stew in my cast iron (no enamel coating) pot, the flavor is 100 times richer and full bodied. I wish someone would make a cast iron crock pot.

Posted by: JB on September 20, 2008 1:32 PM

My husband and I made this stew last night for dinner and it was tremendous. We had been looking for an authentic Irish stew recipe, our son had gone to school in Ireland for a semester and we had visited him there and enjoyed the stews so much. This was the perfect recipe for us, the taste was amazing and it was easy to make. The Guinness and the red wine were definitely "key" ingredients. Thanks so much for this recipe...........it is a real keeper and the beginning of a new family tradition in our home.

Posted by: Cindy on September 29, 2008 10:24 AM

To "A" that posted the following:
-Posted by: A on June 17, 2007 9:04 AM
Guinness is a stout, not a beer!

Yes well done, Guinness is a stout. But stout is a style of beer. So is pilsner, pale ale, bock, porter and many others...

They are all still beer.

Posted by: Daniel on October 3, 2008 4:23 AM

Love, love, love this recipe. I always double it, now add parsnips and sliced crimini mushrooms. My friends and family beg for me to make it - excellent to serve to a gathering.

Posted by: Julie on October 6, 2008 6:15 PM

Thank you for this recipe. I made it for company last night. It was a fall feast: Irish stew, beet-orange salad, crusty bread and for desert, apple pie and pumpkin cookies! I tripled the stew, but did not have enough potatoes to triple the potato amount, because of that the stew was not as thick as it would have been. However the broth is so delicious that it doesn't really matter!

Posted by: julie on October 14, 2008 5:28 AM

OH Elise! I'm having this now for Sunday dinner. I can't think of a better Fall dish.

I only made a few changes. I dredged my stew beef in seasoned whole-wheat flour, added celery, and cut all of my vegetables - including the onions - very roughly (i.e., I made everything very chunky). I used red potatoes and left the skins on. The earthiness is awesome!

The flavors in this dish are wonderful. I was a bit worried about the bitterness of an extra stout concentrating and about a whole Tbs of Worcestershire, but my fears were very misguided. It's really a great homey meal.

Thanks so much!

Posted by: Nate on October 26, 2008 5:59 PM

We used your stew recipe with venison cut from the sirloin tip roast and a small amount of pork shoulder trimmed of some fat but not all. Friends came during the ingredient mixing and I forgot the onion and the worchester sauce! The flavor was absolutely scrumptous anyhow. It is definitely right up their with our favorite venison dish-steak diane.
Thank you for providing this great recipe.

Dave and Anne Whalen

Posted by: david whalen on October 29, 2008 6:38 AM

I just made this tonight, and it was amazing. My mom used to make a beef stew when I was a kid, and I realized as it got cooler outside that I don't have a recipe for a great stew. I pretty much followed the recipe exactly (not the finest red wine - I used Little Penguin Cab).. and I was pretty much drooling while the aroma filled my apartment. Mmm. Next time I will add some cremini mushrooms, but well, I love cremini mushrooms :o) Thank you!

Posted by: Tiffani Martin on October 29, 2008 6:33 PM

Oh boy, this smells so good!

Now I have read the comments I can't wait to try it.

Thank you.
Garry.

Posted by: Garry on November 2, 2008 10:50 PM

The cold weather is finally starting to stick here in Washington DC, and it's perfect soup/stew weather. My boyfriend and I made this recipe (followed it precisely) and had it for dinner on Saturday. It was delicious! We proceeded to have it for a midnight snack, and then Sunday breakfast, lunch, and dinner. And what do you know... now there's none left!

Posted by: Shelly on November 10, 2008 6:42 AM

This stew was easy to make. The stew had an excellent flavor. I really liked the idea of dipping my baguette/french bread into it, sopping up the tasty flavors. It reminded me a little bit of beef bourginon, but definitely did not carry as strong of a wine flavor. The garlic gave it some depth, without overpowering of the ingredients. I think the next time I make it, I'll add some celery, maybe peas. I'll also dredge the meat into flour prior to cooking, so that it may be a little thicker in consistency in the end. I will definitely make this stew again!

Posted by: susan on November 10, 2008 7:07 AM

Following-up on some previous posts .. any modifications needed recommendations for the slow cooker?

Don't know. I haven't made this in a slow cooker. If you do, and you make changes, please let us know about it. ~Elise

Posted by: B on November 16, 2008 8:14 AM

Very tasty! We didn't have any tomato paste so we tossed in a few fresh tomatoes. Thanks for the recipe.

Posted by: SaraQ on November 30, 2008 7:14 PM

Smells delicious! I know it will be good.

Posted by: Jen on December 14, 2008 3:19 PM

Hi, this looks great - but what measurement is a cup? in terms of volume and weight? I live in Ireland and we never go by cup measurements.

There is a measurement converter in the left side bar of this website which you can use to go from American standard to metric measurements. ~Elise

Posted by: jessica on December 15, 2008 7:12 AM

I made this stew, and was a bit disapointed. It was a little bitter. The second day the bitterness had went away, but the wine taste was very prevalent.

Posted by: amy on December 17, 2008 4:16 PM

My wife and I were VERY PLEASED with the outcome of the stew. We made a few minor changes, using less potato, more beef and added a small amount of mushroom. We were so happy with the first round, we are going to make this again for company tonight. THANK YOU!!!!

Posted by: Demetri on December 26, 2008 5:44 AM

I just made this yesterday and it was fantastic! The only thing I am going to add next time are a few cans of stewed tomatoes.

Posted by: Chris on December 28, 2008 6:35 AM

I have made this many times and this is the best recipe I've tried so far. Thanks so much!

Posted by: Lori on January 3, 2009 12:45 PM

This is an awesome recipe. However, I am surprised that no one mentioned that it is more like a soup than a stew. It did not thicken for me. I like stew to be somewhat thick. So I added a little flour to it and it was perfect.

Posted by: Holly on January 4, 2009 4:40 PM

I made this stew a few months ago and it turned out great!! It also got some rave reviews by a couple of my "testers". Excellent.

Posted by: Rachelle on January 4, 2009 6:33 PM

Made this recipe for the first time and got such GREAT reviews from the family that I can't wait to make it again. The Guinness is a wonderful addition. I used Yukon Gold potatoes rather than russets plus a few other substitutions and voila the best stew I have ever made resulted. Looking forward to trying it with lamb.

As I mentioned above I substituted a few items because that's just the way I cook, so this is a good recipe to experiment with and not be afraid you will mess it up. I spiced up the stew meat as it simmered with some Gebhardt's chili powder and although this isn't necessarily an Irish spice it did taste GREAT. Truly the best stew I have ever made.

Posted by: Fern on January 18, 2009 5:08 PM

Oh my! I made this last night to bring to work for lunch over the rest of the week, well a good portion was gone last night before it ever hit the fridge! Even my 6 year old sister who detests stews and soups in general kept coming back and asking for more.
I was skeptical about the wine and Guiness, but about 10 minutes into the simmering with lid on part...everyone in the house was in the kitchen lifting the lid and asking what it was.
Truly a wonderful recipe! Thank you for sharing...it will certainly become part of my recipe lexicon.

Posted by: Sarah on February 3, 2009 9:35 AM

Tried the slow cooker, made it like most recipes for slow cooker stews I see and threw it all in a pot, put it on low for 6 hours or so. I have nothing to go by but I'll be trying the actual recipe version next time. Meat came out kind of tough and the flavor didn't penetrate anything much. Will experiment some more, only the second time I've used it since I got it for christmas. My jambalaya(recipe #1) was kind of a bust compared to the regular way of making it as well.

Very underwhelmed with this thing. Takes me just as long to cook these dishes on the stove top.

With a slow cooker you really need to brown the beef first. It also helps to sauté the veggies separately (to brown them). So much of the flavor in a stew comes from the browning. So throwing everything in a pot and cooking it slow isn't going to get you the best flavor. It should get you tender meat though. If the meat wasn't tender perhaps you needed to cook it longer (assuming you were using the low setting on your slow cooker). ~Elise

Posted by: Matt on February 3, 2009 6:00 PM

Great recipe!!! My guests loved it. Thanks for sharing.

Posted by: Alice Wijman on February 4, 2009 9:59 AM

I would just like to say that everytime I've used this recipe- and I really mean everytime- it has been absolutely incredible. Everything balances and blends to perfection.

Thank you.

Posted by: Tom on February 8, 2009 11:11 AM

Made the Irish Stew last St. Patricks Day for friends of mine. I know I have done good when there is none left, well there was none left. In fact I managed to only get myself a small bowl of it. I made corn bread to go along with the stew which they said really complimented the stew. Thanks for posting the recipe. Now its a yearly tradition with my friends and family to listen to a Flogging Molly CD, eat a lot of the delicious Irish Stew and watch the movie Boondock Saints. This yearly tradition wouldn't have happened if not for the recipe. Thanks again!

Posted by: Skoggit on February 10, 2009 11:00 PM

My love and I have been fans of this recipe almost since the day you posted it. It was part of our repertoire until I was diagnosed with celiac disease and couldn't have Guinness anymore. However, for Valentine's Day I cooked this stew substituting the gluten-free Green's Endeavor dark ale for the stout. It was as delicious as ever! The ale, made from millet, rice, buckwheat and sorghum, added a little extra zing. Endeavor is a pretty expensive Belgian brew, but I'm sure a Redbridge would work as well. Thanks again for this fabulous recipe!

Posted by: Jessica on February 14, 2009 5:01 PM

Made this for dinner tonight. The kids loved it, the house smelled awesome and there are no leftovers...which isnt really a good thing, I would have liked some for lunch tomorrow.
I sub'd an Australian beer i had on hand (Tooheys New) for the Guiness and added some celery late on. We thickened this up just a lil bit with a cornstarch/water mix, but only a little.
Cant wait to have this again.

Posted by: Matt on February 17, 2009 11:47 PM

I made this last year for my child's first birthday on St. Patrick's day. It was absolutely delicious and people are still asking me for the recipe. I will be repeating it again this year for her 2nd birthday and St. Pat's bash. This may become an annual event!

Posted by: Meredith on March 6, 2009 12:34 PM

This is the best stew ever! I have made it three time in the past two months with different proportions of ingredients, different cooking times, and different wines and beers. All excellent. I think we have settled on more meat and less potatoes (3lbs of cubed round steak to 1.5lbs of potatoes), and a full bottle of beer vs a cup (Theakston's "Old Peculiar" is far and away the best beer yet). The only other variant has been a 1/4 cup of real maple syrup substituted for the sugar. Mmmm!!!!

Posted by: Ross on March 13, 2009 10:26 AM

I made this a couple years ago following the recipe as listed a Epicurious, but we like it so much better with the stout and the wine as you say. I add a couple beef bones when browning the meat, use Yukon Gold potatoes instead of russets, and use fresh thyme from our garden rather than dried. We really enjoy this stew.

Posted by: Andrea on March 14, 2009 12:14 PM

Thanks for this great recipe, Elise & Tomas! Made it tonight to cheer myself up on a work-filled St. Patrick's Day night and it did the trick!

I only had about 4.5 cups of beef broth, so I added the whole can of Guinness and maybe 2 cups of wine. Threw in a couple of bone-in stew pieces, and added some sliced mushrooms as I love mushrooms. Also added 1/2 a can of diced tomatoes, and though it is tasty, I might leave it out the next time as it does change the flavour noticeably. Finally, I pureed some of the potatoes at the end and added it back into the stew, along with some cornstarch, to thicken it up. I love an earlier commenter's idea about serving as individual pot-pies, must try this sometime.

A tiny bit heavy on the prep work, but this is REAL food people... definitely worth it! Besides, it's mostly just chopping, so there's not much to clean up after. If the description, photo, and all these comments haven't persuaded you yet, you must try this recipe! SO good.

Posted by: Glitterati on March 17, 2009 8:32 PM

If you are debating whether you should make this or not... do what I did, make it! You will not be disappointed. Best stew I have ever had. It leaves this warm taste in your mouth. I think it works for all seasons. Trust me.

I added celery and it worked out great. I think celery, potatoes and carrots go great together.

Posted by: Caitlin on March 17, 2009 11:47 PM

I made this last night in honor of St. Patrick's day, and I'd say it was an all right, but not exceptional recipe. I'm with the other reviewrs who said that it lacked "oomph". I was expecting it to taste like a stew, of course, but it was just sort of blah tasting and reminded me why I am not much of a stew fan in general.

I followed the recipe exactly (until the very end when I added in a small slurry of cornstarch and water to make the broth slightly thicker, but I tasted before and after and there was no noticeable change in taste), and I used only fresh ingredients of good quality - fresh 7 Deadly Zins wine, good beef stock, no hormone added stew meat (as per the label), ingredients purchased the day before, the dried thyme was only a couple months old... I cooked in a Le Crueset-style dutch oven, like one of the previous reviewers who was not impressed, maybe that has something to do with it? The only thing I can possibly think of that might have effected the stew was that the stew meat I used was extra lean, and I noticed when browning it that it didn't have as much of a "beef-browning" smell as I would have expected, and I really didn't have enough fat on top to warrant draining it off. So maybe that was it, but even so, it's not likely that I'll make this a second time to see if I could get it better.


Hi Lindsay, In my opinion, one should never use "extra lean" meat for anything that requires slow cooking that you want to taste good. There, I've said it. That's my opinion and I'll stand by it. I'm going to adjust the recipe to make sure that people know they should be using the most flavorful and marbled cut for stew meat, which is chuck. Thank you for reporting back. Clarifying this point will help avoid future instances of "lack of oomph" stew. ~Elise

Posted by: Lindsay on March 18, 2009 8:17 AM

Thanks for the response, Elise. I have to admit, aside from pre-formed beef burger patties I've only ever previously purchased beef one time in my life (and I've been doing the daily cooking for 10 years). I just don't eat a lot of red meat, and I cook with it even less. I didn't know that I shouldn't have chosen an extra lean cut of meat for this - I told the guy behind the counter that I needed some stew meat, and this is what he told me to get. :(

Maybe I will give the recipe a go another time. I had such high hopes for it...

Posted by: Lindsay on March 18, 2009 10:42 AM

I just made this in the crockpot. I browned the meat slightly and then popped it in with all the ingredients on low for 9 hours. It was very tasty. I added one extra tablespoon of Worcestershire sauce for a little more of a kick. Everyone liked it quite a bit. They added a little salt/pepper for their own taste. The only suggestion they made was to add some flour at the end to thicken it. Otherwise thumbs up.

Posted by: Amber on March 18, 2009 7:51 PM

Awesome stew! I cooked it in the crock too and my stew meat was lean and required little skimming but it was still tasty.

Crockpot tip: The above recipe goes into a 5+ Quart crock so if yours is smaller, you'll need to reduce the broth and veggie amounts. I learned the hard way with my 3.5Q crock.

This stew can handle all the additions in the comments so read away and modify to your heart's delight.

Posted by: Lisa_S on March 19, 2009 3:44 PM

I made this for St. Patrick's day and have to say it was AWESOME! I am definitely adding it to my list of favs. I am going to try it next in the crock pot and maybe add some frozen peas at the end. What a delicious meal to come home to after a busy day!

Posted by: Mary Custance on March 22, 2009 8:26 AM

My family doesn't normally eat stew, but this recipe has brought them around. Twice in two weeks by popular demand. Not too many dishes get that reception in my house... WOOHOO!

Gotta say, the marbled meat recommendation is excellent advice for any stew... you gotta "fatten" the flavor, and lean meat won't do it. I also think homemade stock is helpful to round out the richness of this or any stew. Boil them bones.. mmmm mmmm good!

Posted by: TimGee3 on March 26, 2009 1:11 AM

I love this recipe.

Posted by: Dean Brown on May 26, 2009 8:32 AM

What a GREAT recipe! I normally DO NOT like stew, but this recipe (which we cooked in the crock pot) has a great "beefy" taste.

Posted by: Joe Schmo on May 29, 2009 6:24 PM

I made this beef stew yesterday with a few substitutions/additions. Used left over white wine (chardonnay) instead of red, german lager instead of guinness, chicken "better than bouillon" instead of beef stock. I added mushrooms and pattypan squash. It still came out really well in spite of all the changes!

Posted by: dw on July 1, 2009 8:02 PM

What kind of red wine shall I use here as there are many types of wine available? Can I just simply get a bottle of red wine and use it? Pls advise..

Use a red wine that you like to drink, in other words, one that is good enough to drink or serve with dinner. If you don't have any favorite wines, I would recommend looking for a midrange pinot noir. ~Elise

Posted by: Chester Fung on July 10, 2009 8:03 AM

Awesome! Used fresh thyme and added flour to the veggies when I cooked them and a little more flour as I went along to make it thick. I also added a little more garlic and omitted the bay leaves because I don't like them. I salted and peppered the beef before I browned it. Finally, I drank two Guinness while I prepared the stew and that seemed to help the flavor too!

Posted by: Rain on August 6, 2009 10:51 PM

I cooked this recipe the other night for my husband and his parents. I took a risk tweaking it to use in my crock pot...but it was a delicious hit! I wanted to share this with others in case they weren't making it because of the time-factor. Maybe it's even better cooking it the way it's intended, but I wouldn't have made it otherwise, so I think it was worth it! I omitted the butter and sugar, only put a splash of olive oil, and had to decrease the amount of stock by about half (not enough room). Thanks for sharing this recipe!

Posted by: Kristin Conroy on October 6, 2009 11:49 AM

Great stew! The only time consuming part of it was the prep of all of the vegtables. I added mushrooms, celery, and rutabaga (substituted for 3 cups of potatoes). I served it with biscuits and my husband loved it. We have plenty left over for another dinner and a couple lunches. I would definitely make this one again.

Posted by: Kristin on October 16, 2009 5:49 AM

man oh man... this is AMAZING! I made this for the 3rd time and thought it was the best yet. The difference this time I used "Better than Bouillion" and I think this brought it to a whole new level. *way better than regular beef broth* I also doubled the meat and halfed the potatoes and added a few parsnips. Elise...thanks again for a phenomenal recipe. ;o), Anna...
ps. next time my husband is going to make some spaetzle to go with it...mmmmm

Posted by: anna on October 21, 2009 2:34 PM

I thought this stew had great flavor, though the "gravy" was too thin for my liking. Next time I will add a slurry, or better yet, toss the beef in flour prior to browning. Having to sautee the veggies before placing in stew was a nice touch. This recipe made a ton, so I brought some into work and it was a huge hit!

Posted by: john on October 30, 2009 11:08 AM

I made this stew last night. It is delicious, but a little too thin, so I added some flour at the end. Also, I cut my potatoes too small and they liquified, so be sure your potatoes are about an inch. Finally, use a 12" skillet to brown the poatoes, carrots,and onions rather than a large pot -- you'll get better browning. Overall, a very tasty stew. Serve over egg noodles, spaetzel, or mashed potatoes and you'll be happy.

Posted by: Hal on November 1, 2009 11:18 AM

I came across your blog when I was searching for an Irish Beef Stew recipe. I do not usually leave comments on blogs but your recipe was simply DELICIOUS and I wanted to let you know. Will definitely make this one again! I'm also looking forward to trying the other recipes on your blog!

Posted by: Aileen on November 2, 2009 9:22 PM

I also never leave comments on blogs, but this stew is so delicious. I used porter and shiraz, but any very dark beer and flavourful red wine should work. Next time I'm going to cut the oil by half or more because my only complaint was that it was quite oily, especially on the second day. (Maybe it was something I did). I'm also going to play around with other vegetables, like fennel, turnips or mushrooms. Great recipe!

Posted by: Eileen on November 6, 2009 10:38 AM

I did this in the crock pot for 10 hours (due to convenience for my schedule). I did a number of the recommendations (with a few of my own), and it was wonderful. I definitely need to do this one again.

Basically, I used the butter to brown the meat (sear the edges) and saute the onions and garlic in a cast iron dutch oven. I placed those and my cut up veggies in the crock pot. I then put the beer, wine, dried mushrooms, and all the sauce ingredients in the dutch oven and cooked for a minute or two to clean the pan. Then I poured it all in the crock pot. Again, 10 hours on low, and it was awesome.

My variations included the following:
-A 3 pound or better piece of chuck roast, which I left whole. I didn't cut it all up. It just falls apart after 10 hours.
-Lotsa Dried Shiitake Mushrooms (AWESOME!!!)
-1 Parsnip
-1 Rutabaga
-2 Tablespoons of Worcestershire sauce, instead of one
-A full bottle of Guinness
-1 red onion, as well as one white one

I bought a leek, but forgot to put it in. I guess, next time. Top rate for this recipe.

Posted by: Bigmike on November 7, 2009 1:54 PM

Like a few others, I don't normally leave comments on blogs, but after making this dish last night I totally felt compelled. Simply delicious. I did not change a thing, other than forgetting to pick up fresh parsley.

The stew had so much flavor, and the texture of the meat and vegetables are perfect, the vegetable don't get so mushy as to not have any of their on flavor or qualities. My husband and I will be fighting over the leftovers today I'm sure!

My husband and 9 year old raved about it as well. This will be my new and only Irish Beef Stew recipe from now on.

Thank you for the great recipe, I am completely hooked on your site now!

Posted by: MJ on November 16, 2009 6:43 AM

Made this fabulous stew for my husband's 60th birthday gathering today. It was a hit with everyone and is a keeper sure to be repeated for many future guests. This is the 5th or 6th recipe I have used from your site and have been happy with them all. Thank you so much!

Posted by: celine on November 23, 2009 7:06 PM

I'm going to make this recipe tonight ... after reading all the posts, I'm going to try lamb. Has anyone tried mushroom broth instead of beef?

Posted by: monika on November 24, 2009 1:01 PM

Mate this stew is incredible. Got another on the go for tonight's meal!
Made it once before and can't get it out my head!
Bring on the snow and awful cold weather...!
Stew stew stew

Posted by: richie p on November 25, 2009 7:18 AM

This is fantastic! Thank you for posting. I was unable to run out and get the Guiness so I skipped it and added an extra cup of stock -- it worked out well. (I'll try the "real" thing next time.) Bravo!

Posted by: Jessica on November 29, 2009 6:49 PM

I was looking for a tasty stew for a cold night, and found this recipe. I used different potatoes and added a little flour. I cooked it on low in the crockpot for 10 plus hours. It was great! At first I was worried that there was too much thyme for my taste, but the crock pot mellowed the flavor out nicely. I used shiraz red wine. I served the stew with yeast rolls and butter. Plus, now I have 5 Guinness Extra Stouts in my fridge for future batches and a tasty mug to go with my stew. Bring on the cold weather!

This recipe is a keeper. Thank you!

Posted by: Holly on December 6, 2009 7:33 AM

Hello -
This turned out great but with the addition of some cornstarch for thickener and reducing the potatoes to roughtly 2 1/2 (I might even do 2 net time) and upping the beef a bit.
I think next time I will put some sweet potatoes in there as well as rutabaga.
The addition of celery turned out well too. Only about 3 stalks or so is perfect.
Thanks for the recipe!

Posted by: Danica on December 14, 2009 12:19 PM

This is FANTASTIC stew, and my wife says it's the best meal I've ever made! I used 1 1/2 cups Guinness and 1 1/2 cups Lindeman's Cabernet. Also used extra carrots & potatoes, and cooked the stock more like 3 hours instead of just one. I ended up adding some corn starch at the end to thicken it up a bit, but other than that followed the recipe pretty closely. Even my four year old (a picky eater) loved it, and everybody had seconds. Really rich and flavorfull.

Posted by: Bill on December 20, 2009 9:01 PM

I made this recipe tonight with Guiness and the Bota Box Shiraz. It was FABULOUS!

I include 3 teaspoons of mild chili powder and used 1/3 cup of tomato paste because the stew just seemed to call for it as the wine, thyme, Guiness, bay and beef were bubbling away when I stirred in the first dose of tomato paste. I meant to add sauteed fennel bulb, but didn't get to it.

Posted by: dharmaBum on December 27, 2009 9:11 PM

Love this recipe. I used lamb instead of beef and it was delicious.

Posted by: Melissa on January 6, 2010 5:14 PM

This stew was scrumptious. The man loved it and got to drink the rest of the guiness and the child kept going "mmmm" when I fed it to her. I used a nice napa cab sav and it was perfect for a snowy winter day. I drank some of the red wine while I cooked the veggies-cooking them in butter really made them yummy. Oh how the carrots added the right sweetness against the complexity of the wine, beer and beef flavors. My stew meat wasn't very fatty (not a lot to choose from at store), but it still came out DELICIOUS. I LOVE THIS SITE!

Posted by: Erin on January 21, 2010 9:12 AM

Awesome! Totally worth the effort. Could go a little lighter on the thyme but otherwise fantastic!

Posted by: Sam Chandler on February 3, 2010 7:28 PM

I've made this stew many, many times over the past few years, and it's always fantastic. Thanks so much for this wonderful recipe!

Posted by: Catherine on February 4, 2010 10:40 AM

This was great fun to make and I expect it to taste great. I made a roux with a couple tablespoons of seasoned flour and cooked it with the browned beef. There's so much liquid in this recipe that I thought it would want thickening. We'll see....it's in the oven now (another alteration from your recipe, which calls for stove-top cooking). I'll let you know.

Posted by: Michael on February 5, 2010 10:20 AM

My DH and I really enjoyed this recipe. I added turnips and parsnips because I had them on hand. I think the key is cooking the vegetables seperately. Thanks for the great recipe!

Posted by: Marjorie on February 11, 2010 8:08 PM

I made this stew tonight for dinner. In a word, "delicious". This made one awesome stew.

Crock pot variations:

1. The night before, I browned the beef as directed, then removed the beef to the crock pot.

2. I then sauted the garlic in the same pan, and removed that and the remaining juices and olive oil to a bowl.

3. Saute the vegetables as directed. Once they're done, they go in the crock pot too.

4. The crock pot, and the bowl with the garlic and juices go in the fridge overnight.

5. In the morning, add the garlic, juices, spices, beer, wine, broth, etc. to the crock pot. This *fills* a 5 quart crock pot.

I used a whole can of Guinness (14.9 oz.) since I couldn't think of anything else to do with 6 oz. of Guinness first thing in the morning.

I slightly cut the broth, since I didn't have exactly 6 cups on hand.

Cook on High for about 4 hours, then switch to Low and cook for about another 4 to 5 hours.

Posted by: David on March 9, 2010 9:06 PM

Made this stew for the third time and it is amazing. I add dried mushrooms reconstituted it red wine and add the juice to the stew. Some homemade french bread and my own glass of stout and I am in heaven. Thanks for sharing.

Posted by: Allen on March 14, 2010 1:33 PM

Made this recipe for St. Patrick's day. I omitted the red wine and added a bit more beef broth so that I could have a stronger Guinness taste. After bringing it to a boil, I put into a 300 degree oven for 2 hours to make the beef more tender. Turned out great.

Posted by: Lowell U on March 14, 2010 4:40 PM

I made this stew a while back for company and remembered that it turned out very bitter. I thought that it was the guinness? I had to add a sweet soy sauce at the last minute in a panic to take away the bitter bite. From reading all the reviews I must surely have done something wrong. I was going to redo the recipe again today without the Guinness but really want the taste that everyone else is raving about in these reviews. Anyone know what might have caused the bitterness that everyone seemed to taste in my stew?

Posted by: Nicole on March 15, 2010 11:29 AM

Hi Elise! I just wanted to let you know that I made this a few days ago and absolutely fell in love with it! It is my favorite stew ever. Thanks so much for the recipe.

Posted by: Joanne on March 17, 2010 5:06 AM

Today being St Patrick's Day, I've just made this stew. I think it turned out good. I'll see what my Irish husband has to say about it. I could not find bay leaves at my Foodlion, so I did it without it. I thought 1tbsp thyme may be a bit too much for me, but it was ok. I guess I stirred it too often at the end that potatoes dissolved some and made the stew very thick. But it still tastes pretty good. I like eating it with some rice. (I'm Japanese and I'd like to eat many kinds of food with white rice anyway.) Thank you for the great recipe.

Posted by: hito on March 17, 2010 10:05 AM

Post a comment

(Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.)

Link to this recipe

Bookmark this page using the following link: http://simplyrecipes.com/recipes/irish_beef_stew/

Do you have a website? You can place a link to this page by copying and pasting the code below.

<a href="http://simplyrecipes.com/recipes/irish_beef_stew/">Irish Beef Stew</a>